4 thoughts on “First round of paper reviews are in”
If this is the peer review of your dendro paper, no surprise. Since folk very committed to dendroclimatology are the natural reviewers, and their self-documented behavior has not been the best, you can expect a rough time. If it has not already occurred to you, I would consult with Steve McIntyre when he returns from his world travels. He documents many of his interactions with the paleoclimatolgy community on his blog – http://climateaudit.org/.
Ecologically Oriented 
If this is the peer review of your dendro paper, no surprise. Since folk very committed to dendroclimatology are the natural reviewers, and their self-documented behavior has not been the best, you can expect a rough time. If it has not already occurred to you, I would consult with Steve McIntyre when he returns from his world travels. He documents many of his interactions with the paleoclimatolgy community on his blog – http://climateaudit.org/.
It was. It has been a rough time indeed, and it’s not over yet I’m afraid.
Just found your 2011 AGU poster. What was the reaction?
I couldn’t go to the meeting. It was placed on the meeting’s “ePosters” site but that gets very little attention. So basically, nobody knows about it.