Not for lease or for sale

In late 1875, the United States government attempted to obtain the Black Hills of South Dakota from the Sioux, by buying them, after reneging on an 1868 treaty that had designated the area as Indian territory, under conditions that essentially precluded whites from ever getting their hands on it.  But gold was discovered a few years later, and both miners and the military began breaking the law by trespassing into the region.  This lead directly to the Battle of The Little Bighorn, one of the most well known events in American history, in which Native Americans mercilessly exacted upon the United States Army some degree of revenge for the abuse, lies, thievery and aggression dealt to them over a very long time.  Dee Brown summarizes the basic story in his now classic book, Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee:

From the Missouri River on the east to the Bighorn country on the west, all the nations of the Sioux and many of their Cheyenne and Arapaho friends had gathered there [on the White River]–more than twenty thousand Indians.  Few of them had ever seen a copy of the treaty of 1868, but a goodly number knew the meaning of a certain clause in that sacred document:  “No treaty for the cession of any part of  the reservation herein described…shall be of any validity or force…unless executed and signed by at least three fourths of all the adult male Indians, occupying or interested in the same.”  Even if the commissioners had been able to intimidate or buy off every chief present, they could not have obtained more than a few dozen signatures from those thousands of angry, well-armed warriors who were determined to keep every pinch of dust and blade of grass within their territory…

During three days of speech making, the chiefs made it quite clear to the Great Father’s representatives that the Black Hills could not be bought cheaply if at any price.  Spotted Tail finally grew impatient with the commissioners and asked them to submit a definite proposal in writing.  The offer was four hundred thousand dollars for the mineral rights; or if the Sioux wished to sell the hills outright the price would be six million dollars… (This was a markdown price indeed, considering that one Black Hills mine alone yielded more than five hundred million dollars in gold).

Red Cloud did not even appear for the final meeting, letting Spotted Tail speak for all the Sioux.  Spotted Tail rejected both offers, firmly.  The Black Hills were not for lease or for sale.  The commissioners packed up, returned to Washington, reported their failure to persuade the Sioux to relinquish the Black Hills, and recommended that Congress disregard the wishes of the Indians and appropriate a sum fixed “as a fair equivalent of the value of the hills.”  This forced purchase of the Black Hills should be “presented to the Indians as a finality”

Thus was set in motion a chain of actions which would bring the greatest defeat ever suffered by the United States Army in its wars with the Indians, and ultimately would destroy forever the freedom of the northern Plains Indians.

Dee Brown, Bury my Heart at Wounded Knee pp 280-284

Image: Sitting Bull

6 thoughts on “Not for lease or for sale

  1. Worth remembering — Custer led the expedition looking for, and found, the gold.
    In 1868 a treaty between the U.S. and the Sioux called for the abandonment of military posts in the Indian territory and established all the land west of the Missouri River for use and occupation of the Sioux Nation. The government was then committed to preventing white men from encroaching in the territory.

    The Custer Expedition of 1874 is contributed with the eventual withdrawal of the treaty and the opening of doors to the white man for exploration and colonization. Col. George Custer spent nearly two months exploring and recording the area around and within the Black Hills. It was during this trip that gold was discovered in French Creek in the southern Hills near the current town of Custer.

    • Custer led the military reconnaissance and opened the “Thieves Road” that gold rushers followed, but Brown says miners were already in there in 1872. But regardless, the treaty of 1868 prohibited both. Brown says Custer was referred to as “Hard Backsides Custer”

  2. yeah, Custer wasn’t the first to find gold there. The history makes hard reading:

    “The Most ultimately righteous of all wars is a war with savages. The rude, fierce settler who drives the savage from the land lays all civilized mankind under a debt to him…it is of incalculable importance that America, Australia, and Siberia should pass out of the hands of their red, black, and yellow aboriginal owners, and become the heritage of the dominant world races.”

    The Winning of the West Vol. 4
    The Indian Wars Page 56 by President
    Theodore (Teddy) Roosevelt

  3. But the white people don’t only _take_ stuff from the land.
    Sometimes they bring stuff to the land from far away, and leave it there:

    “… the acting Director of the USGS in Washington, D.C., Arthur Baker…. argued in a letter to the AEC dated February 28, 1963, that the radioactive material had been dispersed to harmless background levels, and “the extreme cold coupled with the permafrost in the area causes disturbed ground to freeze solid early in the winter and to remain frozen. (Author’s note: The top one to two feet thaws in the summer and freezes again in the fall.) It is believed from previous experience in the area that the dispersal mound is now frozen solid and that the portion of the burial mound containing the waste material will remain solidly frozen and inaccessible for many years, barring a drastic climatic change.”

  4. Wow, good stuff Hank. And there are geneticists out there that still hold that the human race is no longer evolving physically. Hard to understand sometimes how such intelligent people can have so little common sense.

Have at it

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s